Purina Beneful vs. Bil-Jac Dog Food: 2023 Sib piv

Cov txheej txheem:

Purina Beneful vs. Bil-Jac Dog Food: 2023 Sib piv
Purina Beneful vs. Bil-Jac Dog Food: 2023 Sib piv
Anonim

Kev yuav khoom noj dev rau koj tus khub tuaj yeem yog ib txoj haujlwm nyuaj, tshwj xeeb tshaj yog muaj ntau lub khw muag khoom hauv lub txee. Muaj cov npe tshiab tau tshwm sim txhua xyoo, tab sis cov neeg feem coob ua raws li cov hom uas lawv tau loj hlob nrog. Thaum qee tus tau daig rau lawv cov zaub mov qub, lwm tus tau txhim kho lawv cov qauv kom tau raws li cov neeg siv khoom xav tau.

Peb xaiv ob hom uas tau nyob ib puag ncig los saib seb lawv tau ua li cas rau ib leeg. Purina Beneful thiab Bil-Jac tau nyob ib puag ncig rau qee lub sijhawm, txawm tias Purina yog lub npe neeg feem coob yuav paub. Nov yog peb qhov sib piv qhov tob ntawm Purina Beneful thiab Bil-Jac.

pob txha
pob txha

A Sneak Peek at the Winner: Purina Beneful

Purina Beneful siv cov nqaij tiag tiag thiab cov khoom xyaw flavorful los ua ib qho ntawm cov khoom noj dev nrov tshaj plaws nyob ib puag ncig. Thaum Bil-Jac muaj qee cov zaub mov txawv, nws poob qis hauv ntau pawg piv rau Beneful. Peb pom zoo kom sim Purina Beneful Originals thiab Beneful High Protein, tshwj xeeb tshaj yog tias koj tus dev nquag.

Tus yeej ntawm peb qhov kev sib piv:

Purina Muaj txiaj ntsig
Purina Muaj txiaj ntsig

About Purina

Purina's History

Txawm hais tias Purina tsis raug tsim los txog rau xyoo 2001, Purina lub hauv paus pib mus deb tshaj qhov ntawd. Dab tsi pib ua lag luam pub tsiaj me me hauv xyoo 1894 hu ua Robinson-Danforth lub tuam txhab maj mam loj hlob mus rau hauv kev lag luam loj hlob hu ua Ralston Purina tuam txhab hauv 1901.

Thaum kawg, Ralston Purina tau yuav los ntawm Nestle, ua ke nrog lawv cov khoom siv miv tam sim no los ua ib lub tuam txhab khoom noj tsiaj loj tshaj plaws nyob rau lub sijhawm ntawd. Tom qab kev sib koom ua ke, Purina Pro Plan xaiv dev noj zaub mov tau tsim los muab cov dev noj zaub mov zoo, sib npaug.

Purina as a Company

Purina thiab nws keeb kwm tau nyob ib puag ncig, yog li lawv tau koom nrog ntau qhov chaw. Xyoo 2011, Nestle Purina tau txhawb nqa Westminster Dog Show, ib qho ntawm cov dev loj tshaj plaws nyob ib puag ncig.

Nestle Purina kuj tau txais ib qho khoom plig hauv xyoo 2011 rau nws cov kev tsim khoom tsim thiab kev txo cov khib nyiab hu ua Malcolm Baldrige National Quality Award.

Dog Saib
Dog Saib

35% OFF ntawm Chewy.com

+ DAWB Shipping ntawm Tsiaj Khoom Noj thiab Khoom Siv

Yuav ua li cas txhiv qhov kev thov no

Cov teeb meem kev cai lij choj & kev tsis sib haum xeeb

Purina foob Blue Buffalo hauv 2014, hais txog lawv cov kev tshaj tawm txog lawv cov khoom xyaw. Blue Buffalo tau thov kom tsis muaj cov khoom lag luam, tab sis Purina qhov kev kuaj sim tau hais tias lwm yam. Blue Buffalo counter-sued nrog tib daim ntawv thov, nrog rau ob qhov kev foob thaum kawg daws.

Purina raug foob hauv 2015 tom qab tus neeg siv khoom noj tau mob los ntawm lawv cov zaub mov. Qhov no yog vim cov additive propylene glycol, uas muaj me ntsis kom tsis muaj ntaub ntawv ntawm nws cov kev cuam tshuam rau canine noj qab haus huv. Tom qab kev foob thib ob hauv xyoo 2017 rau kev tshaj tawm cuav, lub tuam txhab tsis tau muaj kev foob txij li.

Pros

  • A ntev keeb kwm ntawm kev ua tsiaj txhu
  • Purchased by Nestle
  • Sponsored the Westminster Dog Show
  • Won khoom plig rau kev coj ua

Cons

  • Tau raug foob los ntawm cov neeg siv khoom
  • Siv questionable cov khoom xyaw yav dhau los
doggiedivider
doggiedivider

About Bil-Jac

Bil-Jac's History

Tom qab tsim cov zaub mov txawv rau cov dev uas tsis muaj zaub mov xav tau, Bill thiab Jack Kelly pom lawv txoj kev mob siab rau tsiaj thiab khoom noj khoom haus. Lawv nrhiav tau Bil-Jac xyoo 1947, nrog rau cov khoom noj dev khov ua lawv thawj cov khoom.

Los ntawm lub 80s, Bil-Jac launched nws firsts qhuav aub zaub mov hu ua Adult Select. Niaj hnub no, lub tuam txhab tau ntxiv ntau yam khoom noj dev, nrog rau ntau yam zaub mov qhuav. Txawm hais tias lawv tsis yog lub npe nrov tshaj plaws, lawv tau tuav lawv qhov chaw ntawm lub rhawv ntawm cov khw muag khoom dev loj.

Bil-Jac as a Company

Bil-Jac tau pib ua tsev neeg lub tuam txhab thiab tau txuas ntxiv ua lag luam hauv tsev neeg. Lawv sim khaws tib txoj kev khuv leej thiab cov zaub mov txawv raws li cov thawj tsim, dhau mus ua lag luam nrog txhua tiam neeg.

Cov teeb meem kev cai lij choj & kev tsis sib haum xeeb

Txawm hais tias lub tuam txhab tau nyob ib ntus, tsuas muaj ib qho kev foob uas lawv tau koom nrog. Xyoo 2014, Mars Inc. tau foob Bil-Jac txog kev ntim khoom uas zoo ib yam li lawv tus kheej, tab sis rooj plaub yog poob.

Rau Keeb Kwm Ntawm Purina thiab Bil-Jac

Purina

  • 2016: Purina Pro Plan Savor (cov khoom noj ntub dej) tau rov qab los vim muaj zaub mov tsis muaj nqi
  • 2013: Purina Ib qho khoom noj dev tau yeem rov qab los vim muaj peev xwm kis tau tus kab mob salmonella
  • 2012: Purina Veterinary Diets OM Kev Tswj Kev Nyuaj Siab tau rov qab los vim cov qib taurine tsawg
  • 2011: Purina miv zaub mov (tsis paub ntau yam) tau rov qab los rau qhov xav tias muaj kab mob salmonella

2012: Qee lub hnab ntawm Bil-Jac cov khoom noj dev qhuav tau rov qab los rau cov pwm tuaj yeem loj hlob thiab kis kab mob

The 3 Most Nrov Purina Beneful Dog Food Recipes

1. Purina Beneful Originals (Beef)

Purina Beneful IncrediBites
Purina Beneful IncrediBites

Purina Beneful Originals yog hom khoom noj dev nrov nrog nqaij nyug, zaub, thiab cov nplej tag nrho. Nws tau tsim nrog 23 cov khoom noj tseem ceeb uas koj tus dev xav tau rau kev noj zaub mov kom zoo, nrog cov nqaij tiag tiag ua thawj cov khoom xyaw. Purina Beneful tsis kim heev rau qhov zoo, tshwj xeeb tshaj yog piv rau lwm hom nrov. Txawm li cas los xij, nws muaj cov pob kws thiab cov kua txiv hmab txiv ntoo, uas pom muaj nyob rau hauv cov khoom noj dev feem ntau zoo.

Pros

  • Nqaij nyuj, zaub, thiab cov nplej tag nrho
  • Ua nrog 23 yam khoom noj tseem ceeb
  • Nyob rau qhov zoo

Cons

Made nrog pob kws thiab soy

2. Purina Beneful High Protein (Nqaij qaib thiab nqaij nyug)

Purina Muaj txiaj ntsig
Purina Muaj txiaj ntsig

Purina Beneful High Protein daim ntawv qhia yog zoo meej rau cov kis las thiab ua haujlwm dev. Cov ntsiab lus muaj protein ntau nrog cov vitamins thiab minerals muab rau koj tus dev kev txhawb nqa thiab lub zog xav tau rau cov hnub ntev sab nraum zoov. Daim ntawv qhia no yog ua los ntawm cov khoom sib tw thiab crunchy kibble rau ntau tsw thiab textures. Zoo ib yam li lwm cov zaub mov muaj txiaj ntsig, nws muaj cov khoom xyaw uas tsis muaj zaub mov noj.

Pros

  • Supports athletic dogs
  • High protein ntau daim ntawv qhia
  • Tender thiab crunchy textures

Cons

Nrog cov khoom xyaw ua kom puv

3. Purina Beneful He althy Weight (Nqaij qaib)

Purina Muaj txiaj ntsig
Purina Muaj txiaj ntsig

Purina Beneful He althy Weight yog ib daim ntawv qhia txo calorie rau cov dev uas yuav xav tau kev pab me ntsis hauv lub cev hnyav. Nws tau ua nrog nqaij qaib tiag tiag, yog li qhov tsw tsis tau txi rau kev tswj qhov hnyav. Zoo li lwm cov zaub mov zoo, nws tseem muaj zog nrog cov vitamins thiab cov as-ham uas xav tau rau kev noj zaub mov kom tiav. Hmoov tsis zoo, nws tau ua nrog pob kws, kua, thiab nplej uas tuaj yeem ua rau muaj kev tsis haum tshuaj thiab lwm yam kev txhawj xeeb txog kev noj qab haus huv.

Pros

  • Reduced calorie recipe
  • Muaj qaib tiag tiag
  • Thov kom noj qab haus huv

Ua nrog pob kws, soy, thiab nplej

Peb Nrov Nrov Tshaj Plaws Bil-Jac Dog Food Recipes

1. Bil-Jac Adult Select Formula (Nqaij qaib)

Bil-Jac Cov Neeg Laus Xaiv Cov Nqaij Nqaij Nqaij Nqaij Qhuav
Bil-Jac Cov Neeg Laus Xaiv Cov Nqaij Nqaij Nqaij Nqaij Qhuav

Bil-Jac Adult Select Formula dog food is made with farm-raised chicken as the first ingredient. Daim ntawv qhia no yog tsim nrog cov proteins, rog, thiab carbohydrates, kom muab koj tus dev tag nrho kev txhawb nqa thiab khoom noj khoom haus. Nws kuj tseem muaj cov khoom muaj txiaj ntsig Omega-3 thiab Omega-6 fatty acids rau lub plawv thiab lub tsho tiv no. Ntawm daim ntawv, nws zoo li cov khoom noj dev uas muaj txiaj ntsig zoo, tab sis nws tau ntim nrog ntau yam khoom los ntawm cov khoom thiab cov khoom khaws cia.

Pros

  • Tshuaj-tso qaib yog thawj cov khoom
  • Npaj protein, rog, thiab carbohydrate daim ntawv qhia
  • Muaj Omega-3 thiab Omega-6 fatty acids

Cons

Multiple by-products thiab preservatives

2. Bil-Jac Picky Tsis Muaj Ntxiv (Nqaij Nqaij Qaib)

Bil-Jac Picky Tsis Muaj Cov Me Me Me Me Me Me Me Me Me Me Me Chicken Liver
Bil-Jac Picky Tsis Muaj Cov Me Me Me Me Me Me Me Me Me Me Me Chicken Liver

Bil-Jac Picky Tsis Muaj Ntxiv yog tsim tshwj xeeb rau cov dev uas tig lawv lub qhov ntswg rau txhua yam. Cov nqaij qaib tiag tiag yog nplua nuj thiab ntim nrog saj yog li cov dev picky yuav pom zoo rau nws. Nws yog tsim nrog tib daim ntawv qhia raws li tus thawj Adult Select, fortified rau tag nrho cov khoom noj. Nws muaj preservatives (BHA) thiab pob kws cov khoom xws li lwm yam Bil-Jac zaub mov txawv. Txawm li cas los xij, qhov no tuaj yeem yog qhov kev xaiv zoo yog tias koj tab tom khiav tawm ntawm kev xaiv zaub mov rau koj tus dev picky.

Pros

  • Tshwj xeeb rau cov dev picky
  • Real qaib siab rau tsw
  • Kev noj zaub mov zoo ib yam li qub tsw

Cons

Contains BHA thiab pob kws

3. Bil-Jac Txo Fat (Nqaij qaib)

Bil-Jac Txo cov rog
Bil-Jac Txo cov rog

Bil-Jac Txo Fat dog zaub mov zoo ib yam li cov neeg laus xaiv thawj, tab sis muaj cov ntsiab lus rog tsawg rau kev pab tswj qhov hnyav. Nws muaj fiber ntau sib xyaw los pab hauv kev zom zaub mov, yog li nws yog qhov zoo rau cov dev uas xeev siab los ntawm cov khoom noj dev niaj hnub. Txawm li cas los xij, thawj cov khoom xyaw yog nqaij qaib los ntawm cov khoom lag luam thiab tsis yog nqaij qaib tag nrho, yog li daim ntawv qhia no tsis zoo li lwm tus. Nws kuj tseem muaj cov pob kws thiab cov tshuaj tua kab mob, uas muaj nyob rau hauv cov khoom noj dev hauv qab no.

Pros

  • Less fat content than original
  • Fiber muab los pab digestion

Cons

  • Nqaij qaib los ntawm khoom yog thawj cov khoom xyaw
  • Contains preservatives and corn

Purina Beneful vs. Bil-Jac Sib piv

Thaum saib thawj zaug Purina Beneful thiab Bil-Jac zoo li txawm tias muaj txiaj ntsig zoo thiab lwm yam, tab sis muaj tus yeej meej tom qab saib qhov tob. Peb piv ob hom khoom hauv ntau yam, tsw, cov khoom xyaw, thiab tus nqi. Nov yog cov txiaj ntsig:

Variety: Purina Beneful

Purina Beneful thiab Bil-Jac ob leeg muaj ntau yam tsim nyog xaiv los ntawm, tab sis Beneful muaj ntau txoj kev xaiv thiab zaub mov txawv. Beneful muaj ntau txoj kev xaiv rau cov dev nrog kev ua xua, nrog rau ntau cov zaub mov txawv hnub nyoog.

Flavor: Bil-Jac

Ob lub npe muaj cov zaub mov txawv, tab sis Bil-Jac sawv tawm Beneful nrog lawv daim ntawv qhia Picky Tsis Muaj Ntxiv. Nws tsis yog qhov khoom noj muaj txiaj ntsig zoo tshaj plaws hauv kev sib piv rau Beneful, tab sis nws yog ib qho kev xaiv uas txawm tias cov neeg noj zaub mov nyuaj nyuaj rau dhau mus.

Cov khoom xyaw: Purina Beneful

Thaum nws los txog rau cov khoom xyaw, ob qho tib si Beneful thiab Bil-Jac yuav tsum rov xav txog kev siv cov khoom xyaw muab tub lim. Txawm li cas los xij, Cov zaub mov muaj txiaj ntsig tsuas muaj tsawg dua thiab cov khoom xyaw zoo dua. Bil-Jac kuj tseem siv BHA, cov tshuaj tiv thaiv nrog kev tsis sib haum xeeb hauv cov khoom noj.

Value: Purina Beneful

Purina Beneful thiab Bil-Jac muaj tus nqi sib txawv, nrog Purina Beneful yog tus nqi qis dua ntawm ob. Thaum nws los txog rau tus nqi rau koj cov nyiaj, Beneful yog tus yeej vim nws pheej yig dua rau cov khoom xyaw zoo dua.

Dog Saib
Dog Saib

35% OFF ntawm Chewy.com

+ DAWB Shipping ntawm Tsiaj Khoom Noj thiab Khoom Siv

Yuav ua li cas txhiv qhov kev thov no

Conclusion

Tom qab sib piv ob hom khoom noj dev qhuav, tus yeej yog Purina Beneful. Nws tsuas yog ua los ntawm cov khoom xyaw thiab cov khoom noj zoo dua qub. Yog tias koj tus dev yog tus neeg noj zaub mov noj, Bil-Jac Picky Tsis Muaj Ntxiv yuav yog qhov kev xaiv rau koj. Txwv tsis pub, peb xaiv Purina Beneful tawm ntawm ob lub npe no.

Zoo siab tias, peb tau pab koj nrhiav zaub mov zoo. Ob qho khoom noj dev muaj lawv qhov zoo thiab qhov tsis zoo tab sis tej zaum yuav tsis zoo rau koj tus dev. Yog tias koj tsis paub meej, nug koj tus kws kho tsiaj kom pom zoo ua ntej pib noj zaub mov tshiab.

Pom zoo: