Royal Canin vs Hill's Science Diet Dog Food: 2023 Sib piv

Cov txheej txheem:

Royal Canin vs Hill's Science Diet Dog Food: 2023 Sib piv
Royal Canin vs Hill's Science Diet Dog Food: 2023 Sib piv
Anonim

Royal Canin thiab Hill's Science Diet yog ob lub npe nrov uas haum rau hauv ib qho chaw zoo sib xws, cog lus rau kev tshawb nrhiav tsiaj txhu zoo thiab pab pub dev ntawm txhua yam, suav nrog cov neeg muaj mob hnyav. Ob leeg muaj kev txhawb nqa Veterinary thiab tau pom zoo los ntawm ntau tus kws kho tsiaj. Tab sis yog tias ntsib nrog kev xaiv ntawm ob lub npe, nws tuaj yeem nyuaj kom paub qhov txawv. Ntawm no yog kev sib piv ntawm ob hom thiab lawv cov zaub mov nyiam.

A Sneak Peek at the Winner: Hill's Science Diet

Hill's Science Diet yog peb lub npe pom zoo rau cov dev feem ntau, nrog rau cov khoom qab zib, noj qab nyob zoo, noj zaub mov zoo, thiab ntau yam kev xaiv. Lawv daim ntawv qhia nqaij qaib thiab mov yog ib qho ntawm peb txoj kev nyiam, tab sis yog tias koj tus dev tsis nyiam nqaij qaib lossis muaj kev ua xua, lawv cov nqaij yaj noj yog lwm qhov kev xaiv qab.

About Royal Canin

History

Royal Canin tau tsim muaj nyob rau xyoo 1968 los ntawm tus kws kho tsiaj Fab Kis uas nrhiav kev daws teebmeem rau kev noj qab haus huv los ntawm kev noj qab haus huv. Lub hom phiaj nthuav dav hauv xyoo 1972 thaum nws tau yuav los ntawm lub tuam txhab loj, thiab txij li ntawd los, nws tau dhau los ua tus thawj coj hauv kev tshawb fawb tsiaj txhu rau dev thiab miv. Lawv txhawb nqa tsiaj encyclopedias, tsim cov chaw kho mob rog rog rau tsiaj, thiab ua ntau yam khoom noj.

Products

Royal Canin muaj peb hom zaub mov tseem ceeb: cov zaub mov loj, cov khoom noj yug me nyuam, thiab cov khoom noj tsiaj. Lawv cov zaub mov raws li qhov loj me yog cov khoom noj tsiaj uas zoo tshaj plaws rau qhov ntau thiab tsawg thiab hnub nyoog pawg-piv txwv li, cov khoom noj me me loj. Lawv cov zaub mov raws li kev yug me nyuam yog tsim rau cov tsiaj tshwj xeeb, zoo li Golden Retriever zaub mov, thiab tsim rau cov dev purebred. Thaum kawg, lawv muab ntau yam khoom noj uas yuav tsum tau txais kev pom zoo los ntawm kws kho tsiaj.

Pros

  • Proven hom keeb kwm
  • Nutritious zaub mov
  • Higher protein
  • Higer fiber ntau

Cons

  • Ntau dua
  • Siv nqaij los ntawm cov khoom

About Hill's Science Diet

History

Hill's Science Diet pib nrog tus dev coj tus mob raum thaum xyoo 1900s. Thaum tus aub tus tswv coj nws mus rau kws kho tsiaj, Dr. Mark Morris, Dr. Morris xav tias kev hloov zaub mov tuaj yeem pab tswj tus kab mob. Nws txoj kev noj haus tau ua haujlwm, thiab thaum xyoo 1940, Dr. Morris tau koom tes nrog Hill Ntim Tuam Txhab los tsim Hill's Science Diet. Niaj hnub no, lub tuam txhab yog tswv los ntawm Colgate-Palmolive Group thiab yog ib qho kev nyiam ntawm vets thoob ntiaj teb.

Products

Hill's Science Diet tsim cov khoom noj khoom haus thiab tshuaj, ib yam li Royal Canin. Lawv cov zaub mov txheem tuaj nyob rau ntau hom, suav nrog cov khoom noj rau kev noj qab haus huv uas tsis xav tau kev kho mob, xws li cov zaub mov hauv plab. Lawv kuj muaj cov khoom noj tsis haum rau cov khoom noj thiab cov zaub mov poob. Zoo li Royal Canin, lawv muaj ntau yam khoom noj ua rau dev ntawm qhov sib txawv thiab hnub nyoog. Lawv kuj muaj ntau cov zaub mov noj dev noj.

Pros

  • High noj haus
  • Proven hom keeb kwm
  • Multiple tsw profiles
  • Tus nqi qis

Cons

  • Lower protein cov ntsiab lus
  • Non-meat protein boosts
  • Cov khoom tsis txaus ntseeg

3 Nroj Tsuag Nroj Tsuag Canin Dog Zaub Zaub Recipes

1. Noob nom noob tswv Canin Size Noj Qab Haus Huv Nruab Nrab qhuav Khoom noj

Royal Canin Size Kev Noj Qab Haus Huv Nruab Nrab Qhuav Khoom Noj
Royal Canin Size Kev Noj Qab Haus Huv Nruab Nrab Qhuav Khoom Noj

Royal Canin cov zaub mov nrov tshaj plaws sab nraum lawv cov zaub mov noj yog lawv cov zaub mov nruab nrab. Cov zaub mov no yog tsim rau cov dev ntawm 23-55 phaus. Nws muaj kev txhim kho kibble tsim los txhawb kev zom thiab sib npaug khoom noj khoom haus, nrog 23% crude protein, 12% roj crude, thiab 3.2% fiber. Cov khoom xyaw tseem ceeb yog brewers mov, nqaij qaib los ntawm cov khoom noj, oat groats, nplej, pob kws gluten pluas noj, thiab nqaij qaib rog. Nws feem ntau yog chij liab kom pom lwm yam uas tsis yog nqaij lossis nqaij noj raws li thawj cov khoom hauv cov zaub mov no, thiab nws hu rau cov lus nug seb 23% protein mus txog li cas.

Tsis yog cov khoom tseem ceeb ntawm cov protein, nqaij qaib los ntawm cov khoom noj lossis pob kws gluten pluas noj, yog qhov zoo. Nqaij qaib los ntawm cov khoom noj yog cov khoom noj nqaij qaib ntau los ntawm cov khoom qis. Pob kws gluten pluas mov yog ib qho pheej yig cog cov protein. Cov nroj tsuag cov proteins tsis zoo tagnrho thiab cov dev tsis tau txais cov khoom noj muaj txiaj ntsig ntau ntawm pob kws gluten pluas noj raws li lawv xav tau los ntawm nqaij qaib lossis cov khoom noj zoo sib xws.

Pros

  • 23% protein
  • Txhim kho kibble tsim

Cons

  • Ntshai tsis yog thawj zaug
  • Nqaij qaib los ntawm khoom xwb
  • Plant protein

2. Noob nom noob tswv Canin Size He alth Loj qhuav zaub mov

Royal Canin Size Kev Noj Qab Haus Huv Loj qhuav zaub mov
Royal Canin Size Kev Noj Qab Haus Huv Loj qhuav zaub mov

Royal Canin Size Kev Noj Qab Haus Huv Loj Cov Khoom Noj yog pom zoo rau cov dev uas hnyav 56 txog 100 phaus thiab yog ib qho ntawm Royal Canin cov zaub mov nrov tshaj plaws. Nws yog kwv yees li 24% crude protein thiab 15% roj crude-siab dua lwm yam khoom ntawm daim ntawv teev npe no. Nws kuj yog optimized rau loj breeds nyob rau hauv lwm txoj kev, nrog ntau cov as-ham los txhawb cov pob txha thiab sib koom noj qab haus huv thiab kibble uas yog tsim los rau cov dev loj. Cov khoom xyaw tseem ceeb yog nqaij qaib los ntawm cov khoom noj, brewers mov, nplej, xim av mov, nqaij qaib rog, thiab pob kws gluten pluas noj. Nqaij qaib los ntawm cov khoom noj yog ib qho khoom noj nqaij qaib uas ua los ntawm cov nqaij qaib tsawg tsawg. Nws yog cov khoom noj nqaij qaib qis dua. Brewers mov, hom qoob mog thiab xim av yog cov zaub mov noj qab haus huv uas yooj yim zom. Nqaij qaib rog yog qhov muaj rog thiab noj qab nyob zoo hauv cov zaub mov dev.

Pros

  • 24% protein
  • Zoo rau cov dev loj
  • He althy whole grains

Cons

  • Nqaij qaib los ntawm khoom xwb
  • Zaub protein

3. Royal Canin Size Noj Qab Haus Huv Me Me

Royal Canin Size Noj Qab Haus Huv Me Me
Royal Canin Size Noj Qab Haus Huv Me Me

Royal Canin cov zaub mov me me yog tsim rau cov dev uas hnyav txog 22 lbs. Lub kibble loj thiab cov khoom noj khoom haus tshuav yog optimized rau cov kev xav tau ntawm cov dev me. Cov zaub mov no yog 25% protein thiab 14% rog-zoo tagnrho rau tus dev ntawm qhov loj. Cov khoom xyaw tseem ceeb yog pob kws, nqaij qaib los ntawm cov khoom noj mov, brewers mov, nplej xim av, thiab pob kws gluten noj. Txoj cai zoo ntawm tus ntiv tes xoo yog tias cov nqaij yuav tsum yog thawj cov khoom xyaw. Txawm hais tias muaj kev noj qab haus huv, cov khoom noj muaj protein ntau uas tsis ua raws li txoj cai no, qhov tseeb tias cov khoom xyaw thawj, thib peb, thiab plaub yog tag nrho cov nplej yog kev txhawj xeeb. Nqaij qaib los ntawm cov khoom noj kuj yog qhov tsis zoo, cov nqaij tsis zoo.

Pros

  • 25% protein
  • Designed rau me dev

Cons

  • Ntshai tsis yog thawj zaug
  • Nqaij qaib los ntawm khoom xwb
  • Zaub protein

The 3 Most Popular Hill's Science Diet Dog Food Recipes

1. Hill's Science Diet Qaib & Barley

Hill's Science Diet Chicken & Barley dev zaub mov
Hill's Science Diet Chicken & Barley dev zaub mov

Hill's Science Diet Chicken & Barley yog ib qho ntawm cov khoom noj uas nyiam tshaj plaws thiab yog qhov kev xaiv zoo rau cov dev noj qab nyob zoo. Nws muaj 20% crude protein, 11% roj crude, thiab 4% crude fiber. Qhov ntawd muab tso rau hauv qis kawg ntawm qhov zoo tshaj plaws spectrum rau cov protein thiab rog cov ntsiab lus, tab sis nws tseem yog ib qho kev xaiv noj qab haus huv. Thawj cov khoom xyaw hauv cov zaub mov no yog nqaij qaib, ua raws li barley, nplej, pob kws, thiab sorghum. Tag nrho cov no yog cov nplej tag nrho uas muaj txiaj ntsig zoo. Nws kuj tseem muaj cov zaub mov taum pauv, cov khoom noj muaj protein ntau uas tsis muaj kev noj qab haus huv dua li cov nqaij proteins.

Cov zaub mov no muaj cov omega fatty acids, E-vitamins, thiab antioxidants uas txhawb lub tsho, sib koom, thiab tiv thaiv kab mob kev noj qab haus huv thiab flavorful, yooj yim-rau-siv cov khoom xyaw.

Pros

  • Nqaij qaib yog thawj cov khoom xyaw
  • No by-products
  • He althy added vitamins thiab minerals

Cons

  • Lower protein thiab rog ntau
  • Plant-based protein pluas mov nrog

2. Hill's Science Diet Lamb Meal & Brown Rice

Hill's Science Diet Lamb Meal & Brown Rice
Hill's Science Diet Lamb Meal & Brown Rice

Yog tias koj xav pub koj tus dev lwm yam tsis yog nqaij qaib, Hill's Science Diet Lamb Meal thiab Brown Rice yog ib qho kev xaiv. Nws muaj 19.5% crude protein thiab 12.5% roj crude, me ntsis qis tshaj qhov zoo tagnrho tab sis tseem nyob rau hauv ib txwm muaj. Qhov tseem ceeb ntawm cov protein nyob hauv cov zaub mov no yog nqaij yaj noj, ib qho nqaij yaj uas noj qab nyob zoo thiab qab. Nws ua ib qho kev xaiv zoo rau cov dev uas tsis nyiam yaj. Cov nplej tseem ceeb yog nplej xim av, brewers mov, sorghum, nplej, pob kws, thiab barley. Qhov kev sib xyaw ntawm cov nplej no muab rau koj tus dev kom ntau cov nplej, tab sis cov ntsiab lus ntawm cov protein tsawg qhia tias cov zaub mov no yuav yog carb hnyav. Kev sib xyaw ntawm E-vitamin, omega fatty acids, antioxidants, thiab lwm yam khoom noj pab txhawb nqa koj tus dev kev noj qab haus huv tag nrho. Cov zaub mov no pom zoo rau cov dev hnub nyoog ib txog rau rau xyoo.

Pros

  • Zoo qaib sib ncaws
  • He althy lamb and whole grain food
  • He althy added vitamins thiab minerals
  • No by-products

Cons

Carb hnyav thiab qis hauv cov protein

3. Hill's Science Diet Sensitive Skin thiab plab

Hill's Science Diet Sensitive tawv nqaij thiab plab
Hill's Science Diet Sensitive tawv nqaij thiab plab

Hill's Science Diet yog qhov paub zoo rau nws cov khoom lag luam rau cov dev uas muaj teeb meem kev noj qab haus huv, suav nrog lawv cov tawv nqaij rhiab heev thiab plab hnyuv. Cov zaub mov no yog ua los ntawm cov nqaij qaib, barley, thiab mov yooj yim kom nws yooj yim rau dev plab. Nws muaj vitamin E thiab omega fatty acids uas zoo rau cov dev uas muaj tawv nqaij rhiab heev. Nws muaj 20% crude protein thiab 13% roj crude. Cov ntsiab lus ntawm cov protein yog me ntsis ntawm qhov kawg, tab sis nws tseem nyob hauv qhov ntau ntawm cov khoom noj uas tau txais. Ib yam uas peb tsis nyiam txog cov zaub mov no yog qhov thib peb cov khoom xyaw yog daj peas. Peas yog cov khoom noj dev tsis sib haum xeeb uas tau siv los ua cov khoom noj khoom haus thiab muaj qee qhov txuas rau cov teeb meem kev noj qab haus huv hauv lub plawv uas tseem tab tom kawm. Muaj peas siab ntawm cov khoom xyaw yog hais txog.

Pros

  • Formulated rau rhiab dev
  • Vet-recommended
  • Contains prebiotics for plab he alth

Cons

  • Peas yog peb cov khoom xyaw
  • Muaj me ntsis hauv cov protein

Rau Keeb Kwm ntawm Royal Canin thiab Hill's Science Diet

Hill's Science Diet tau muaj ntau qhov rov qab los. Kev rov qab tsis ntev los no yog xyoo 2019 thaum Hill's Science Diet rov qab txog 45 yam khoom vim muaj vitamin D toxicity. Qhov no tshwm sim thaum cov zaub mov dev muaj ntau cov vitamin D ntxiv. Thaum Lub Kaum Ib Hlis 2015, Hill tau tshaj tawm qhov tshem tawm qee yam khoom noj kaus poom rau qhov tsis paub tias tsis cuam tshuam rau zaub mov kev nyab xeeb. Thaum Lub Rau Hli 2014, 62 lub hnab zaub mov hauv California tau rov qab los vim muaj peev xwm kis tau tus kab mob Salmonella. Thaum Lub Peb Hlis 2007, Hill's Science Diet yog ib qho ntawm ntau tshaj 100 lub npe uas tau ntsib kev rov qab los vim muaj kev phom sij uas muaj melamine.

Royal Canin kuj tseem muaj ntau qhov rov qab los. Lawv kuj raug cuam tshuam los ntawm 2007 melamine rov qab. Lawv tau tshaj tawm thib ob rov qab ob peb lub hlis tom qab rau tib yam teeb meem raws li thawj zaug rov qab. Thaum Lub Ob Hlis Ntuj xyoo 2006, lawv tau rov qab los vim qhov nce qib vitamin D3 hauv qee yam ntawm lawv cov zaub mov.

Royal Canin vs Hill's Science Diet Comparison

Cons

Taste

Ntug: Royal Canin

Royal Canin muaj lub koob npe nrov rau qhov tsw zoo, nrog ntau yam khoom noj ntub thiab qhuav uas muaj qab ntxiag thiab qab ntxiag textures uas dev nyiam. Hill's Science Diet yog qhov zoo sib xws, tab sis nws tsis muaj lub koob npe nrov ntawm cov tswv.

Cons

Nutritional Value

Ntug: Hill's Science Diet

Feem ntau, Hill's Science Diet muaj cov khoom xyaw zoo dua, tab sis Royal Canin muaj protein ntau thiab fiber ntau. Hill's Science Diet tsis siv nqaij qaib los ntawm cov khoom noj hauv nws cov zaub mov tseem ceeb, thiab lawv feem ntau muaj cov nqaij tiag tiag ua thawj cov khoom xyaw. Ob leeg nyob ntawm cov nroj tsuag cov proteins rau qee qhov hauv lawv cov zaub mov.

Cons

Price

Ntug: Hill's Science Diet

Ob lub npe zoo nkauj zoo nkauj, thiab yog tias koj tus dev tsis muaj teeb meem kev noj qab haus huv, lwm hom yuav zoo dua. Txawm li cas los xij, Hill's Science Diet feem ntau pheej yig dua hauv nws cov khoom siv dav dav thiab cov kws kho tsiaj.

Cons

Selection

Ntug: Hill's Science Diet

Ob lub npe tsim ntau yam khoom noj khoom haus. Royal Canin kuj tsim cov kab ntawm cov khoom noj tshwj xeeb. Tab sis thaum nws los txog rau cov khoom noj dev dav dav, Hill's Science Diet muaj ntau txoj kev xaiv, cov khoom noj tshwj xeeb, thiab lwm yam kev xaiv los pab koj tus dev noj cov zaub mov zoo tshaj plaws.

Cons

Txhua

Ntug: Hill's Science Diet

Txhua yam, peb nyiam Hill's Science noj zaub mov rau lawv cov kev tshawb fawb zoo, tus nqi qis, thiab keeb kwm ntev ntawm kev nqa zaub mov zoo rau cov tsiaj xav tau. Noob nom noob tswv Canin tuaj yeem yog cov khoom noj zoo heev thiab hauv qhov xwm txheej zoo li cas los xij.

Conclusion

Ob tog Hill's Science Diet thiab Royal Canin muaj lawv qhov zoo thiab qhov tsis zoo, tab sis thaum kawg, peb txiav txim siab tias Hill's Science Diet yog qhov kev xaiv zoo tshaj plaws. Hill's Science Diet yog cov khoom noj muaj txiaj ntsig thiab feem ntau tuaj ntawm tus nqi qis. Nws kuj muaj ntau txoj kev xaiv muaj thiab feem ntau yog ib qho kev xaiv zoo dua rau cov dev xav tau kev noj zaub mov tshwj xeeb. Txawm li cas los xij, nws muaj cov protein tsawg dua Royal Canin, thiab qee cov dev ntawm kev noj zaub mov noj yuav ua tau zoo dua nrog cov khoom lag luam Royal Canin.

Pom zoo: