CARNA4 vs Orijen Dog Food: Peb 2023 In-depth Comparison

Cov txheej txheem:

CARNA4 vs Orijen Dog Food: Peb 2023 In-depth Comparison
CARNA4 vs Orijen Dog Food: Peb 2023 In-depth Comparison
Anonim

Lub ntiaj teb cov zaub mov dev tuaj yeem ua rau tsis meej pem rau kev taug kev. Cov chaw tsim khoom noj tsiaj muaj cov yam ntxwv sib txawv tab sis zoo li cog lus tias lawv yog qhov zoo tshaj plaws. Ib qho muaj ntau pua cov khoom xyaw, feem ntau koj tsis tuaj yeem hais, ib qho muaj protein ntau, thiab lwm yam tsis muaj nplej. Yog li, koj xaiv qhov twg?

Txhawm rau pab koj nrog qhov kev txiav txim siab no, peb niaj hnub saib qee lub npe loj tshaj hauv khw. Niaj hnub no, peb tab tom saib Carna4 thiab Orijen, ob qho tib si cog lus tias cov khoom xyaw zoo thiab qhov zoo tshaj plaws rau koj tus menyuam dev.

Nyeem mus nrhiav seb tus twg los saum toj thiab yog vim li cas.

A Sneak Peek at the Winner: Orijen

Thaum ob lub npe zoo heev, Orijen yog peb tus yeej. Nws txoj kev mob siab rau koj tus dev noj zaub mov thiab noj qab haus huv yog tsim nyog rau tus nqi hwm, uas thaum kawg yog pheej yig dua li nws qhov kev sib tw.

About CARNA4

CARNA4 muaj npe raws li tus vajtswv poj niam Carna, uas cov neeg Loos Ancient ntseeg tau tiv thaiv lawv cov kabmob hauv nruab nrog cev thiab pab lawv lub cev tau txais zaub mov los ntawm zaub mov.

Lawv Pom qhov sib txawv hauv khw

CARNA4 yog tsim los ntawm David Stauble thiab Maria Ringo. Lawv ntseeg tias kev pub mis nyuj nyoos yog qhov zoo tagnrho tab sis nkag siab tias nws tsis zoo rau txhua tus niam txiv dev. Yog li, lawv tsim CARNA4, uas yooj yim tab sis tsis cuam tshuam rau qhov zoo.

Nkauj tawm tshiab

Maria thiab Dave tau koom tes nrog pab pawg kws ua zaub mov noj, engineers, thiab cov kws tshawb fawb txog zaub mov, thiab lawv muaj 50 xyoo ntawm kev sib koom ua ke hauv kev lag luam khoom noj dev.

Lawv kuj ua haujlwm nrog lub chaw tshawb fawb thib peb, Mortec Scientific Inc., tshwj xeeb hauv kev tsim khoom noj. Cov khoom xyaw yog cog rau ntawm Canadian thiab Asmeskas ua liaj ua teb, thiab cov zaub mov tshaj AAFCO cov qauv. CARNA4 ua haujlwm nrog lwm tsev neeg ua haujlwm uas qhia lawv cov kev xav txog kev ruaj khov, cov khoom noj tsis muaj tshuaj, tsis muaj GMO, thiab kev ua liaj ua teb tib neeg.

CARNA4 tsis yog muaj dav npaum li Orijen, tab sis lawv muaj cov npe ntawm cov khw muag khoom uas npaj lawv cov zaub mov thiab tab tom nrhiav nthuav lawv cov kev sib txuas hauv Asmeskas thiab Canadian.

Cov khoom xyaw

Cov zaub mov txawv txhua yam zoo sib xws, thiab lawv muaj cov zaub mov tsis muaj nplej. Cov ntaub ntawv noj zaub mov koj xav tau yog qhia meej meej ntawm lawv lub vev xaib kom nkag tau yooj yim. Rau txhua daim ntawv qhia, muaj kev sib cais ntawm cov khoom xyaw thiab cov khoom noj khoom haus. Cov os, qaib, thiab ntses tag nrho zaum ntawm 29% protein, 15% rog, thiab 4% fiber.

Muaj ib daim ntawv qhia pub mis rau koj siv yog tias koj tus dev nyob rau theem menyuam dev, tsis muaj zog, lossis tus laus. Lawv pom zoo kom pub mis rau koj tus dev noj tsawg dua li lwm cov khoom noj qhuav vim CARNA4 yog cov concentrated hauv cov khoom xyaw yooj yim absorbed, zoo.

Crossover Ingredients

CARNA4 khaws nws cov npe khoom me me, uas txhais tau hais tias thaum koj tau nyeem ib qho, koj yuav pom qee lub npe zoo ib yam tshwm sim dua li qe, qos yaj ywm, thiab carrots, thiab qee yam hu ua Flora4 uas peb mam tham tom qab.

Muaj, tau kawg, qhov laj thawj rau qhov no: cov khoom xyaw hauv Carna4 yog cov khoom zoo. Hauv peb qhov kev txheeb xyuas qhov tob ntawm cov khoom xyaw, koj yuav pom qee qhov zoo sib xws ntawm cov zaub mov txawv.

Pros

  • Siv cov khoom xyaw zoo
  • Txhua yam ntuj tsim, tsis muaj hluavtaws
  • No vitamin thiab minerals pre-mixes or preservatives
  • Ntsuab thiab nplej tsis muaj muaj
  • Ntau tshaj AAFCO cov qauv

Tsis muaj dav li lwm hom npe

About Orijen

Orijen txuas rov qab mus rau lo lus Latin "keeb kwm," uas hais txog lub tuam txhab lub hom phiaj kom rov qab mus rau thawj cov zaub mov ntawm canines thiab felines. Champion Pet Food yog Canadian-based thiab tsim txhua yam ntawm Orijen cov zaub mov. Lawv muaj ob tsob nroj, ib qho hauv Canada, Alberta, thiab lwm qhov hauv Kentucky, Tebchaws Asmeskas.

orijen rau ntses aub zaub mov ntawm lub phaj noj thiab hauv nws lub ntim
orijen rau ntses aub zaub mov ntawm lub phaj noj thiab hauv nws lub ntim

Three Principal Ideals for Orijen

Tsis zoo li CARNA4, uas muaj ntau dua ntawm kev lag luam me me, Orijen yog tus loj heev. Nws tau tsim nyob rau hauv 1985 thiab muag hauv 70 lub teb chaws. Raws li lub tuam txhab, muaj peb lub hom phiaj tseem ceeb rau nws cov zaub mov.

Ua ntej, lawv cov zaub mov yog lub hom phiaj kom muaj kev lom zem rau cov dev. Muaj kev sib cav txog seb cov dev yog cov tsiaj txhu los yog omnivores, thiab Orijen hais txog qhov tsim ntawm tus dev, nws cov hniav canine, puab tsaig, qaub ncaug, thiab cov enzymes, vim li cas tus dev yog carnivore.

Thib ob, lawv ib txwm siv cov khoom xyaw hauv cheeb tsam, uas txhais tau hais tias lawv yog pob tshab txog qhov twg lawv cov khoom xyaw los ntawm thiab txhawb cov lag luam me, hauv zos.

Thiab thib peb, lawv yeej tsis outsource lawv manufacturing. Qhov no txhais tau tias txhua kauj ruam ntawm kev tsim khoom yog saib xyuas los ntawm Orijen.

Tshuaj ntsuab

Orijen tsuas yog siv cov khoom xyaw tshiab, tsis yog GMO. Lawv yeej tsis siv fillers, by-products, dag xim, flavors, los yog preservatives.

Orijen muaj cov nplej thiab nplej tsis muaj kev xaiv, thiab lawv cov kev noj qab haus huv cov nplej muaj xws li oats, quinoas, thiab chia, ntawm qee qhov kev xaiv tsis muaj gluten. Rau lawv cov zaub mov qhuav, lawv siv 85% / 15% piv, uas txhais tau hais tias 85% ntawm lawv cov zaub mov yog tsim los ntawm cov tsiaj cov proteins, thaum 15% yog los ntawm cov txiv hmab txiv ntoo, zaub, thiab botanicals. Ob feem peb ntawm cov tsiaj proteins yog cov tshiab los yog nyoos, tsim kom muaj cua, cov khoom noj muaj txiaj ntsig zoo.

Ntau txoj kev xaiv

Yuav muaj, koj yuav pom tej yam haum rau koj tus dev vim muaj ntau yam zaub mov txawv. Orijen muaj ntau yam xws li lub neej theem, kev poob phaus, cov qauv khov-qhuav, cov zaub mov qhuav, thiab zaub mov ntub. Txawm li cas los xij, nws yog ib qho ntawm cov khoom lag luam pricier tawm muaj.

Hauv qhov sib piv rau CARNA4, cov khoom xyaw cov npe ntawm Orijen ntev dua. Txawm li cas los xij, qhov no tsis txhais hais tias nws zoo dua los yog phem dua vim qhov tseem ceeb yog qhov muaj npe hauv cov khoom xyaw.

Cov khoom xyaw sib cais

Ntau cov khoom xyaw hauv daim ntawv teev npe yog legumes: liab lentils, pinto taum, ntsuab lentils, navy taum, chickpeas, thiab peas. Sau cov khoom xyaw hauv txoj kev no tau zoo li daim ntawv qhia kev tsim qauv ntawm "cov khoom sib cais." Qhov no yeej yog hais txog kev ua lag luam yuam kev ntawm kev faib cov khoom tsis zoo rau ntau qhov chaw. Qhov no tso cai rau lub tuam txhab sau cov khoom xyaw "xav tau" ua ntej thiab thawb cov khoom xyaw uas tsis xav tau ntxiv rau hauv daim ntawv, tsim qhov kev xav tias muaj tsawg dua ntawm cov khoom tsis zoo hauv cov zaub mov.

Pros

  • Cov khoom xyaw zoo siv
  • Made in Canada thiab U. S.
  • High hauv protein
  • No fillers, by-product, artificial xim, flavors, or preservatives
  • Ua raws AAFCO cov qauv

Kim

3 Nrov CARNA4 Dog Food Recipes

1. CARNA4 Hand Crafted Dog Food Chicken Formula

Duab
Duab

Thawj ob yam khoom xyaw yog nqaij qaib tshiab thiab nqaij qaib siab. Ob leeg yog cov khoom zoo cov txheej txheem ua noj yog maj mam ci kom khaws cov khoom noj zoo tshaj plaws.

Cov qe ntxiv rau cov nqaij qaib thiab nqaij qaib vim lawv kuj yog ib qho zoo heev ntawm cov protein nrog cov amino acids tseem ceeb uas koj tus dev xav tau rau kev loj hlob thiab kev loj hlob ntawm cov leeg. Lub Atlantic Salmon siv yog ceev-kua thiab tau raug-boned. Nws yog qhov zoo heev ntawm cov protein, omega-3, thiab cov vitamins, uas tsim nyog rau kev noj qab haus huv ntawm daim tawv nqaij thiab lub tsho tiv no thiab tiv thaiv kev mob caj dab.

Kev sib xyaw ntawm probiotics, natural enzymes, barley noob, flaxseed, lentils, thiab peas yog hu ua "Flora4" thiab blends natural sources of vitamins, thiab minerals.

Thaum qhov no yog ib qho ntawm cov zaub mov muag zoo tshaj plaws, nws yog ib daim ntawv qhia nqaij qaib, uas yog ib qho kev ua xua. Yog li, nws yog ib yam uas koj yuav tsum paub txog thaum yuav nws yog tias koj tus dev tsis tau muaj qaib ua ntej.

Pros

  • Cov khoom xyaw zoo siv
  • Txhua yam ntuj tsim
  • Ntsuab ci
  • No vitamin thiab minerals pre-mixes or preservatives

Cons

qaib yog ib qho tshuaj tsis haum

2. Carna4 Hand Crafted Dog Food Duck Formula (Grain-Free)

Carna4 Handcrafted Dog Food, Duck
Carna4 Handcrafted Dog Food, Duck

Thawj ob yam khoom xyaw yog duck thiab nqaij npuas siab. Nqaij qaib thiab nqaij nyug yog ob qho ntawm cov nqaij nyiam tshaj plaws, tab sis muaj lwm cov proteins tshiab uas cov niam txiv tsis xav sim, thiab duck thiab nqaij npuas yog kev sib xyaw zoo. Duck yog nplua nuj nyob rau hauv hlau thiab muab koj tus dev nrog lean, yooj yim-rau-digest protein qhov chaw.

Daim ntawv qhia lub siab, ntawm qhov tod tes, muaj 10 txog 100 npaug ntau cov as-ham ntau dua li cov nqaij nqaij. Nws tsis yog tsuas yog ib qho ntawm cov khoom noj muaj txiaj ntsig zoo tshaj plaws xwb, tab sis nws kuj tau ntim nrog hlau, protein, vitamins, thiab fatty acids tseem ceeb.

Tseem kuj muaj herring nyob rau hauv daim ntawv qhia, uas yog ib tug zoo heev qhov chaw ntawm calcium, omega-3, thiab vitamin D rau cov pob txha muaj zog thiab ib tug noj qab nyob zoo lub tsho tiv no thiab tawv nqaij. Nws muaj DHA thiab EPA siab, thiab zoo li ntses salmon, nws kuj tiv thaiv cov mob xws li mob caj dab.

Cov Duck Formula yog nplej dawb thiab zoo tagnrho rau cov dev nrog gluten rhiab heev thiab ua xua. Muaj kev sib txuas ntawm cov kab mob hauv lub plawv thiab cov zaub mov tsis muaj nplej, tab sis kev tshawb fawb tseem tab tom ua, thiab tsuas yog tsis paub txaus txog kev sib txuas ntawm cov zaub mov tsis muaj nplej thiab dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM).

Pros

  • Cov khoom xyaw zoo siv
  • No vitamin thiab minerals pre-mixes or preservatives
  • Suitable for dogs with allergies

Cons

Nco ntsoov tshawb nrhiav tsis muaj nplej

3. Carna4 Tes Crafted Dog Food - Yooj Yim-Chew Fish Formula

Carna4 Easy-Chew Fish Formula Sprouted Seeds Dog Food
Carna4 Easy-Chew Fish Formula Sprouted Seeds Dog Food

The Easy Chew Fish Formula yog tsim los rau tag nrho cov theem ntawm lub neej tab sis nrog ib tug customized softer, me me nugget rau lub qhov ncauj ntawm cov menyuam dev, me me, thiab cov dev laus uas tam sim no muaj teeb meem zom.

Thawj ob yam khoom xyaw yog herring thiab perch. Perch yog nplua nuj nyob rau hauv vitamin B3, calcium, niacin, phosphorus, thiab riboflavin, uas yog ib qho tseem ceeb cov as-ham rau koj tus dev. Cov omega-3 fatty acids kuj muaj txiaj ntsig zoo rau lub plawv noj qab haus huv, uas ua rau perch ib qho ntxiv zoo heev.

Pros

  • Cov khoom xyaw zoo siv
  • No vitamin thiab minerals pre-mixes or preservatives
  • Suitable for dogs with allergies
  • Nrog rau omega fatty acids

Cons

  • Tsis tsim nyog rau qee tus dev
  • Smelly

3 Nrov Orijen Dog Food Recipes

1. ORIJEN Original Grain-Free Dry Dog Food

ORIJEN Original Grain-Free Dry Dog Food
ORIJEN Original Grain-Free Dry Dog Food

Orijen thawj tsib cov khoom xyaw yog ib txwm nyoos los yog cov protein tshiab, thiab nws muaj tseeb rau daim ntawv qhia no. Muaj nqaij qaib, qaib ntxhw, flounder, mackerel, thiab nqaij qaib siab. Daim ntawv qhia kuj muaj qaib ntxhw giblets, nrog rau lub plawv, daim siab, lub plawv, thiab gizzard. Cov khoom xyaw xya yog herring, uas txhais tau hais tias thawj xya cov khoom xyaw yog nqaij los yog ntses. Qhov ntawd yuav luag ua rau cov khoom xyaw ntxiv ntawm cov npe tsis tseem ceeb.

Cov nqaij qaib qhuav hauv daim ntawv qhia no muaj ntau dua plaub npaug ntawm cov protein ntau li nqaij qaib tshiab. Ntxiv rau, tsis zoo li nqaij qaib noj uas suav tias yog cov khoom noj tsis zoo, cov nqaij qaib lub cev qhuav dej tsis raug kub hnyiab, thiab ntau cov nqaij cov khoom noj tau khaws cia.

Tom ntej no yog cov qe, uas yooj yim rau zom thiab muaj protein ntau, fatty acids, thiab vitamins uas txhawb nqa koj tus dev kev noj qab haus huv tag nrho. Daim ntawv qhia no pom meej meej hauv cov protein ntau, uas yog zaum ntawm 38%, thaum cov rog nyob ntawm 18%. Qhov no tej zaum yuav tsis yog kev noj haus rau tus dev uas tsis coj txoj kev ua neej nyob, ua rau nws hnyav, lossis laus dua thiab ua rau txoj kev ua neej nyob qis dua.

Pros

  • Cov khoom xyaw zoo siv
  • High hauv protein
  • Nrog cov omega fatty acids thiab cov roj yam tseem ceeb ntawm ntses
  • Grain-free

Cons

  • Tsis tsim nyog rau qee tus dev
  • Muaj peev xwm allergens

2. ORIJEN Amazing Grains Six Fish Recipe Dry Dog Food

Orijen Amazing Grains Six Fish Recipe
Orijen Amazing Grains Six Fish Recipe

Amazing Grains cog lus 90% cov khoom xyaw tsiaj zoo thiab tsis muaj cov khoom xyaw legume. Cov protein thiab rog yog 38% thiab 18%, feem. Thawj rau cov khoom xyaw yog mackerel, herring, salmon, pilchard, flounder, thiab monkfish.

Oat groats tau teev tom qab ntses, thiab lawv txhais tau tias yuav zom maj mam. Qhov no txo qis glycemic load thiab yuav ua rau koj tus dev puv sijhawm ntev. Tom ntej no yog millet, uas yog nplua nuj nyob rau hauv cov vitamins B, potassium, thiab hlau thiab yooj yim rau dev zom.

Daim ntawv qhia qhia txog qhov zoo tshaj plaws ntawm cov ntses, pob txha, thiab lub cev yog siv los simulate yam koj tus dev cov poj koob yawm txwv noj nyob rau hauv qus. Tau kawg, thaum hma tua nws tsis yog noj cov leeg xwb; nws noj yuav luag tag nrho nws cov tsiaj txhu. Thaum daim ntawv qhia no tsom rau cov nqaij nam, nws kuj tsis yuam kev los ntawm cov lus cog tseg no los ntawm kev ntxiv cov txiv hmab txiv ntoo thiab zaub. Ntxiv rau, cov khoom xyaw xws li pears, txiv apples, thiab cranberries tau ntim nrog cov vitamins thiab minerals uas txhawb nqa koj tus dev kev noj qab haus huv tag nrho.

Pros

  • Cov khoom xyaw zoo siv
  • Nrog rau omega fatty acids
  • Filling

Cons

Tsis tsim nyog rau qee tus dev

3. ORIJEN Regional Red Grain-Freeze-Dried Dog Food & Topper

ORIJEN Regional Red Grain-Freeze-Dried Dog Food
ORIJEN Regional Red Grain-Freeze-Dried Dog Food

Qhov kev xaiv khov-qhuav los ntawm Orijen yog tsim hauv cov khoom me me kom khaws cov khoom noj. Cov khoom xyaw muaj xws li nqaij, ntses, lub cev, thiab cov pob txha thiab pab txhawb qhov zoo ntawm cov vitamins thiab minerals.

npua npua, piv txwv li, txhawb nqa cov nqaij ntshiv thiab kev ua haujlwm, lub plawv thiab lub cev tiv thaiv kab mob kev noj qab haus huv, thiab pab kev txawj ntse. Cov nqaij hauv nruab nrog cev yog cov khoom noj muaj txiaj ntsig ntau dua li cov nqaij nqaij, thiab los ntawm lub siab, muaj cov khoom noj los txhawb kev zom zaub mov, cov plab hnyuv siab raum, lub cev tiv thaiv kab mob, pob txha, thiab kev noj qab haus huv ntawm lub hlwb.

Cov qib protein nyob ntawm 36% thiab cov rog ntawm 35%, ua qhov no siab tshaj plaws hauv ob pawg kom deb li deb. Nrog rau qib siab protein thiab rog, Regional Red yog haum rau cov dev nrog kev ua neej nyob.

Pros

  • Cov khoom xyaw zoo siv
  • Nrog cov as-ham, minerals, thiab vitamins
  • High hauv protein thiab rog
  • Cov txiaj ntsig ntawm cov khoom noj nyoos

Tsis tsim nyog rau qee tus dev

Rau Keeb Kwm ntawm CARNA4 thiab Orijen

Tseem tsis tau muaj ntawv ceeb toom ntawm ib lub tebchaws USA rov qab rau ob qho ntawm cov khoom noj dev no. Orijen cov khoom noj miv tau rov qab los hauv Australia vim muaj teeb meem cuam tshuam nrog nws cov khoom raug kho nrog hluav taws xob ntawm kev lis kev cai. Orijen txij li thaum tau tso tseg nws cov khoom lag luam hauv Australia.

CARNA4 vs Orijen Sib piv

leo txaus siab rau orijen rau ntses dev zaub mov
leo txaus siab rau orijen rau ntses dev zaub mov

Peb nyob ze rau qhov kawg ntawm peb qhov kev sib piv, tab sis ua ntej peb ua tiav, peb muaj ob peb yam ntxiv uas yuav tseem ceeb rau koj thaum txiav txim siab ntawm cov hom no.

Taste

Cov hom khoom sib npaug hauv pawg no, vam khom cov nqaij zoo raws li lawv cov khoom xyaw tseem ceeb. Txawm li cas los xij, Orijen tau txais cov ntsiab lus vim nws siv cov nqaij ntau dua Carna4.

Nutritional Value

Thaum nws los txog rau cov khoom noj muaj txiaj ntsig, cov khoom lag luam uas tawm los saum toj yog nyob ntawm seb koj tab tom nrhiav rau hauv kev noj haus. Orijen muaj qhov nruab nrab nruab nrab ntawm cov protein thiab rog thiab qis dua qhov nruab nrab ntawm cov carbohydrates. CARNA4 muaj qhov siab tshaj qhov nruab nrab ntawm cov protein, qhov nruab nrab feem pua ntawm cov rog, thiab qis dua qhov nruab nrab ntawm cov carbs.

CARNA4 yeej cov qeb rau nws qhov tshwj xeeb siv cov noob sprouted es tsis txhob ua raws li cov txheej txheem cereal nplej uas feem ntau kibbles coj mus muag siv. Nws tseem yog thawj lub npe tsim cov khoom siv hluavtaws-dawb dev uas tshaj li cov khoom noj muaj txiaj ntsig tsim los ntawm AAFCO siv cov khoom xyaw ntuj xwb.

Price

Orijen yeej qhov kev sib tw no vim nws muab ntau txoj kev xaiv, thiab muaj ntau chav rau tus nqi sib txawv; qee cov zaub mov txawv tsis kim li lwm tus.

Selection

Orijen muaj ntau dua, ob qho tib si los ntawm khw muag khoom thiab hauv online, uas ua rau nws yooj yim dua me ntsis, yog li taw tes mus rau Orijen.

Txhua

Vim qhov muaj Orijen yog tus yeej, tab sis nws tau ze dua li nws thawj zaug tshwm sim ntawm ob hom. Txawm hais tias ib tug tseem muaj kev xav ntawm kev lag luam me thiab ib qho loj dua, lawv ob leeg muaj lub tswv yim zoo sib xws.

Conclusion

Thaum xaiv tus yeej ntawm ob lub npe, nws tsis yooj yim rau lub sijhawm xaiv. Thaum ob qho tib si zoo sib xws, Orijen hnyav rau lawv cov nqaij, thaum Carna4 muaj cov npe sib zog ntawm cov khoom xyaw. Txhua cov khoom xyaw uas nkag mus rau hauv ob lub npe yog cov khoom zoo thiab muaj txiaj ntsig zoo. Txawm li cas los xij, Orijen yog tus yeej tag nrho vim nws muaj nyob hauv khw.

Pom zoo: